spot_img
HomeNews & ViewsIndustry FocusHierarchy to Heterarchy: A Crossroads for Textile & Apparel Transformation

Hierarchy to Heterarchy: A Crossroads for Textile & Apparel Transformation

spot_img

COVID-19 revealed a paradox in organizational life: even with half the mid-level workforce physically present and reduced office hours, many companies not only survived but thrived. This disruption exposed inefficiencies in traditional hierarchies – layers of reporting, redundant roles, and micromanagement – that often obstruct value creation rather than enable it.

Instead of information crawling up and down multiple layers of hierarchy, Zoom meetings and digital platforms turned the pyramid into a network. Everyone could see the same dashboards, hear the same updates, and know their role directly. That eliminated the endless chain of “someone reports → someone approves → someone executes.” This is the method the company adopted at that time, which is called ‘heterarchy’. But unfortunately, most of the company went back to their old school; only a few carry some good habits.

Photo: Nazmut Tarek, General Manager, Nahl Fashion Ltd

What if we adopt “Heterarchy” in our industry?

 Conventional hierarchies offered accountability, control, and order. When the world was slower and smaller, it worked. For example, information was hard to get by, communication was delayed, organizations were spread out geographically, formal authority was needed to make decisions, and technology was limited. When the environment shifts, but the structure doesn’t, problems arise. The flow of information has been altered by digital technologies.

Why do organizations still act as though they need to climb a ladder when knowledge is now instantly available?

About 75 years ago, heterarchy was initially introduced in cybernetics by Blackmore. This article explores how it may be improved for today’s intricate social structures and organizations. Distributed authority, various leadership styles, dynamic interactions, reciprocal influence, contextual decision-making, self-organization, and adaptation are Blackmore’s seven interrelated themes. Here, I’ll give a quick description of each:

1. Distributed authority:

Each team holds full authority over its own work and passes it directly to the next team without further back-and-forth. In garment order execution, multiple specialized centres—spinning, knitting, dyeing, cutting, sewing, printing, embroidery, washing, and supply chain—operate in sequence. When every team clearly understands its role and accountability, the entire process flows smoothly as just-in-time execution.

2. Multiple Centres of Leadership:

Heterarchy differs fundamentally from hierarchy. Authority does not automatically follow organizational rank. Instead, leadership shifts according to the situation, expertise, and context.

– Hierarchy asks: Who is above whom?

– Heterarchy asks: Who is best positioned to solve this problem?

In a heterarchical organization, the person leading a decision changes with the issue at hand.

Examples:

– Buyer negotiation → Senior merchandiser leads

– Fabric technical issue → Textile specialist leads

– Production problem → Production expert leads

– Data analysis → Data specialist or AI system leads

– Sustainability compliance → Sustainability specialist leads

The formal organizational chart remains in place.

The decision-making network, however, becomes dynamic.

3. Dynamic relationships:

Leadership can move from person to person as circumstances change. Traditional merchandising organizations suffer from a specific pathology: influence is concentrated in the merchandiser role because merchandisers own the buyer relationship and the order file. Every material delay, quality dispute, or capacity shortfall gets routed through the merchandiser, who then chases the relevant department for an answer. The merchandiser becomes a human switchboard, and the organization becomes a queue of requests waiting for one person’s attention.

The heterarchy model’s dynamic relationship breaks this bottleneck, as leadership moves following influence. When the store department can influence supplier follow-up, the cutting department can push the fabric team directly on delivery schedules, and the dyeing unit can negotiate with the knitting unit without merchandising mediation, the organization gains parallel processing capacity. The merchandiser’s influence remains high on buyer-facing decisions—pricing, order confirmation, relationship management—but not on operational execution decisions that belong to the domain experts. That significantly reduces unnecessary communication.

4. Mutual influence:

Mutual influence in a heterarchical organization means that influence flows in multiple directions—not just downward from formal authority, but upward, laterally, and diagonally based on expertise and proximity to the problem. In a hierarchy, influence is largely positional: the person with the higher title has the final word. In a heterarchy, influence is relational and contextual: the person with the most relevant knowledge or the most immediate stake in the outcome can shape the decision, regardless of rank.

“Think of the game ‘Rock, Paper, Scissors.’ Paper covers rock; rock crushes scissors; scissors cut paper.

Think also of the system of checks and balances in the U.S. Constitution. Different branches of government have supreme authority in some situations, but not in others. And no one is above the law. No kings or tyrants allowed.”

If we would like to consider this case for the apparel industry, Each has genuine influence within their domain, and each must listen to the others when the context shifts.

5. Contextual decision-making:

Beyond standard operating procedures (SOPs), times arise when we must respond to a buyer’s special request. For example, if a buyer requests a compressed lead time of 45 days instead of the normal 60 days, each cross-functional team can provide input to make it possible. In standard practice, vendors usually decline such requests or, if they do say yes, ultimately fail to deliver due to a lack of cross-functional cooperation. True responsiveness emerges when hierarchy becomes fluid – with teams contributing as co-architects, not gatekeepers. Then, heterarchical collaboration becomes a habit, and “yes” transforms from a gamble into a shared commitment.

When a buyer requests 45 days instead of 60, rigid SOPs fail. Declining or overpromising without cross-functional unity breaks trust. True responsiveness emerges when hierarchy becomes fluid – each team contributing as co-architects, not gatekeepers. Then heterarchical collaboration becomes habit, and “yes” transforms from gamble to shared commitment.

6. Self-organization:

In a heterarchy, teams operate as micro-enterprises. Each holds its own P&L and the autonomy to decide where to invest. Clarity of role, purpose, and accountability is universal: anyone can see who does what.

Traditional model vs. heterarchy – the junior role

Traditional: “You are junior, so you observe.”

Learn by watching. Wait for permission. Hold the information. Pass it up. A junior often attends meetings merely as a human backup system.

Heterarchy: “You are junior, so you learn.”

Represent the company. Make recommendations. Negotiate. Escalate intelligently.

7. Adaptability:

 When the world changes, flexible organizations can change with it. The real obstacle isn’t technology – it’s us. We’re so attached to what we’ve always known that we resist new ways of working, even when the tools are right there.

Look at Bangladesh’s garment industry during COVID. Orders worth $3.18 billion vanished almost overnight. The factories that moved fast survived. Fakir turned five plants into PPE units and brought on 400 extra people. Beximco shipped 6.5 million medical gowns in a single month and shifted 60% of its 40,000 workers onto the new work. The capacity was already there; it just needed the freedom to pivot.

That’s the shift we need: from control to trust, from hoarding information to sharing it, from waiting for approval to owning the outcome, from title to real skill, from watching over people to enabling them—and from “who’s senior?” to “who actually knows?”

Conclusion:

Is the heterarchy going to replace the hierarchy? The answer is, it’s not. However, the ladder will undoubtedly get flattened. Heterarchy establishes several centres of power and permits various individuals, groups, or departments to take the lead based on their qualifications and the circumstances. Hierarchy can be described as an interaction between verticalization (formal authority) and heterarchy as a horizontalization (expertise and collaboration).

The managerial position will undergo one significant change. From following up on updates, emails, and regular approvals, managers now define direction, coach staff, resolve ambiguity, manage important relationships, deal with exceptions, and develop capabilities. They no longer serve as information routers, but hierarchy still holds them responsible for results.

The most vital enablers are AI and ERP. They create a common resource out of data. Risks, order status, and bottlenecks are displayed in real time by dashboards and assistants, allowing anybody to take action without waiting for the chain. Information flows: System → People → Decision. AI reduces administrative load; judgment and accountability stay human.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
- Advertisement - spot_img
spot_img

Join Our Weekly Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Simillar News

Recent Random

PM joins Bangladesh Solar Expo-2026

Prime Minister Tarique Rahman joined the opening ceremony of Bangladesh Solar Expo-2026 in the city this morning as the chief guest. The inaugural ceremony began...

Meet Trützschler at ITMA Asia 2026: Innovations for efficient and intelligent fiber processing

From November 20 to 24, 2026, the Trützschler Group will present its latest fiber processing technologies at ITMA Asia in Shanghai, China. Visitors are...

Georg Stausberg takes over as CEO of the Rieter Group with immediate effect

The Board of Directors of Rieter Ltd. was confronted by the designated CEO, Daniel Lippuner, with additional demands regarding his compensation package, particularly his...